Collapsed Bonnybrook train bridge

Unless you’ve been living on the moon you have no doubt heard about the floods that ravaged many parts of Alberta in late June 2013. Record rainfall and melting snow pack in the mountains unleashed a torrent of water with nearly every river and stream overflowing its banks.

Many low lying sections of Calgary were flooded, ruining numerous homes and businesses. Included in those structures damaged is the CPR’s massive Bonnybrook bridge over the Bow River, which failed as a train passed over it. A weakened pier shifted or broke away, causing the centre spans to partially collapse. While the train did not fall into the river, some rail cars dangled precariously above it.

I wanted to go view the bridge and knowing there is a public pathway very near it, we decided it would be fun to bike in. We started at a point on the eastern edge of town, in an industrial area, using the Calgary to Chestemere canal pathway as our route in.

↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ Scroll down for photos and to comment ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓

It takes us little time to travel the approximately ten kilometres to our destination, with only a flat tire to slow us down (I get a lot of flats). Before checking out the bridge we take some time to enjoy lunch, with wine of course.

From our lunch spot we have a pretty good view of the action and it’s amazing to see the bridge damaged as it is. The site is a bee hive of activity with many workers moving about, and lots of machinery, all engaged in cleaning up and fixing the mess.

This event has severed the CPR’s east/west mainline and I am sure the railway is eager to get things back to where they were. This must be costing them, well, a train load of money, both for the repairs and the lost business that likely came about as a result of this event.

This bridge has sat here for approximately one hundred years and while there are those that may say it was its age that contributed to the failure, I don’t buy that. Railways have a philosophy when it comes to their physical plant and they always overbuild and a century old bridge is nothing odd.

Even in spite of its solid construction it could not stand up to the scouring effects of the flood which as I understand it, uncut the trailing edge of the effected support pier (the upstream section of the pier looked fine). There were ongoing inspections above water but there was no way to know what was happening below. However, as long as the bridge remained true, it was a pretty safe bet it was fine. Typically, a failing pier or foundation would be instantly noticeable as parts would shift out of alignment, but that did not happen here and so there was no way to know that a failure was imminent.

At the flood’s peak, the Bow River almost reached the top deck of the bridge.

There are four tracks here, three sharing the span that collapsed, and an additional track on top a second deck on the upstream side. They all share the same piers, which are very wide and this span, built in the 1970s I believe, seemed to be intact. Machinery was using it to get back and forth across the river and it’s possible that a limited number of trains could use this remaining link.

A nearby CNR bridge appeared for the most part, unscathed. I looked down the tracks and they were arrow straight, meaning no visible shifting happened. It is of course entirely possible it sustained some damage that can not be seen by my cursory “inspection”. This one is just upstream.

The majority of the train had passed over the bridge before it failed. A number of tank cars loaded with petroleum products did not make it across and these were a big worry. It was feared they would leak or maybe tumble into the river. In the end however, they were simply emptied of their contents and later re-railed and dragged away. What could have been a catastrophe was quickly averted in a very orderly and business like manner.

This author believes the local media somewhat over dramatized the event. It could have been a huge disaster, there is not doubt about that. However, on closer inspection it was clear there was little chance of the cars falling into the river or even leaking for that matter. They remained completely upright and for the most part unscathed and the bridge while shifted, was mostly intact. Even if it the structure collapsed further, the truss sides would have likely prevented the cars from falling off – even so as a safety measure, they were anchored to other freight cars to keep them from moving. This was a potentially dangerous event, handled systemically and professionally.

In addition to the bridge, it appears some of the track leading from it suffered some damage too and various pieces of machinery were at working realigning everything. Seen directly behind the Bonnybrook bridge is the CPR’s huge Alyth yards.

We take some time to look at the river itself and it’s brown and dirty and still quite high. It’s going to take a long time for things to clear up. So sad.

A quick bike ride back, with no flats this time (knock on wood), and we’re at the car, a good day exploring behind us.

Update: July 09 2013. We returned to the bridge and were able to photograph it from a different angle, again from a public pathway. It was earlier underwater, preventing access until this day. From this direction we have a good look at the damage, although it’s still hard to see exactly what happened. Some Mammoet cranes were stationed on each end of the bridge, ready to do some heavy lifting.

To see an updated report on the bridge, go here…
Collapsed Bonnybrook train bridge – two months later.

We did another report earlier in the year which included some pictures of this bridge, and to view them please click the link below…
Silver Streak movie then and now – cop chase.

If you wish more information about this place, by all means contact us!

Date of adventure: June and July, 2013.
Location: Calgary, AB

  • _________________________

    BIGDoer.com: Doing it Different!



    Something to say in private? Click here to: Reach Us!
    NEWS!First TimersFAQMeet the Team
    BIGDoer.com on Facebook

    If you liked this post, please tip your server…



    Or

    © 2012-2024 Chris Doering, Johanna (Connie) Biggart & the BIGDoer.com Society. 🍁🎀

Fixing bike flat

First things first, I fix a flat, which I get all the time.

Bike ride lunch

After a nice ride it’s time for lunch (with wine).

Bow River floods

The very muddy Bow River as seen from our lunch spot.

CPR Bonnybrook bridge

Our first look at the flood damaged CPR Bonnybrook Bridge.

CNR Bow River bridge

The CNR bridge just upstream seems to have made through the flood unscathed.

Damaged CPR bridge

The middle spans collapsed as a train passed over.

Failed CPR Bonnybrook bridge

This severed the CPR’s east/west mainline.

Fixing CPR Bonnybrook bridge

Crews busily work to repair the damage.

Damaged Bonnybrook bridge

This must be costing the railway train loads of money due to lost business.

CPR Bonnybrook tank car

One of the tank cars involved in the incident. Note the missing coupler.

Bike Ride Calgary Canal

Riding back along the canal.

We revisited the site July 9th and took the following photos…

CP Bonnybrook bridge

A couple weeks later and work continues on fixing the structure.

Collapsed CPR Bow River bridge

The tracks have been removed.

Bonnybrook train bridge

A close up of the damage.

Collapsed CPR bridge

This public pathway was underwater on our last visit.

36 responses

  1. N Thompson says:

    This article introduced me to your work many years ago and I come back often to catch up on what you two are doing. Keep it up!

    Norman

  2. Dina Sutherland says:

    Good Afternoon,

    I am doing a presentation on the Bonnybrook bridge and I was wondering if I could use one of your photos with the crane on the bridge; I would really appreciate it.

    Thanks,
    Dina

  3. Ed Murphy says:

    Thanx for posting info about the rail bridges in the Calgary area. My great uncle Thomas Murphy who I am researching worked for the CPR on the bridge and building crews during the early part of the last century.

  4. Rollie the Human says:

    Amazing reporting! Have you plans to revisit the site again? We’re all waiting!

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Yup, I’ll be dropping by soon. Not sure when, but perhaps in a week or so.

  5. Yvonne M says:

    I drove past the bridge this morning and it appears it’s being completely dismantled.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      I plan on checking the place out in the next couple days or so and will post an update.

  6. John BC says:

    Your reporting is better than anything I’ve seen on the news. Factual, without over the top dramatics.

  7. Neil Doll says:

    I was willing to accept this accident as unavoidable act of nature but with the recent train explosion in Quebec I’m starting to think that the railroads are unsafe.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Keep in mind hundreds of trains operate every day, so accidents are few. However, even I am starting to wonder what’s going on.

  8. Van Der Hall says:

    Based on others comments mine might be a little off topic, but how do you deal with flats? I’ve tried fixing my own but never seem to pull it off. They still leak and I always have a hard time getting all the parts back together. Any advice you could share would be helpful.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      I’ll email you on this, and I’m also thinking on publishing a report on how I handle and fix flats. I get them all the time too, but before that I need to solve why this is happening so much to me. I am experimenting with some advanced solutions as I’ve already tried all the obvious one recommended by bike experts. Every one, bike techs and all, is confused by this, as am I.

  9. Zelok says:

    Kudos, a standing ovation to those skilled workers who have cleaned up and are cleaning up the mess. Well done and I thank the lord you professionals are on the job.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Right, the professional responders should get big thank you. While everyone tossed blame around, these guys cleaned up the site quickly and professionally.

  10. Billy BL says:

    Great shots! I am totally surprised no other bridges in Calgary failed.

  11. Praise God says:

    My son works for the railway in Alberta. He told me the infrastructure is not being maintained and it’s all falling apart with disaster is looming.

    Great blog by the way!

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      I’ve heard that from others who work in the industry and this is worrisome.

  12. Gerry Bowers says:

    I’m glad the train crew made it safely across. Sometimes these things just happen and you know, there’s not much you can do about it.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Indeed, there are some events that you just can’t plan for, for instance a flood of this magnitude. The CPR is not unique in this respect and most of Southern Alberta was caught off guard as well.

  13. Stanley Lucas says:

    Were cars purposely left on that bridge over the coarse of the flood as a means to try and stabilize the bridge? Could this company be so stupid as to use dangerous cargo as dead weight over our water ways. People tell me this is a common practice done be the Railway industry.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Leaving full rail cars on a bridge during a flood is pretty standard procedure. CPR will use loaded grain cars for this purpose since their contents pose no danger should they tumble into the river, and indeed such cars were placed on the line across the Bow River by the Zoo. In this case however, these tank cars were part of a moving freight train, and much of it passed over the bridge before it buckled. The train would have likely been moving very slowly at this point, which helped keep damage to a minimum. We found some of the tank cars involved in the incident nearby (numbers shown on news casts matched) and from the pathway, which was not far from them, we were able to see there was almost no visible damage to them and what there was seemed only superficial. Any worries of the leaking might have been premature or maybe over dramatic. They remained upright and intact.

  14. Yoga granny says:

    My Grandfather had a job with CP Rail, this position was track maintenance/watchman, and he would have to walk the tracks in a certain section to check the rails and do minor repairs, bang in a spike, clear dead animals off the rails, etc,

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      He was a section man! Very cool! At one time every kilometre of track was patrolled by these hard working men.

  15. William Jobs says:

    Today (July 4th) while biking to work I saw a train pass over the undamaged span on the north side. It traveled slowly and there were inspectors watching at each end of the bridge. Or at least I think they were inspectors, as they watched the train very closely.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      I thought CPR might do that. They must be nervous as hell and I bet they are only letting non-dangerous cargo over it. Thanks for posting!

  16. Bobho Walter says:

    Fortunately rail ways have considerable experience dealing with assorted catastrophes and disasters. Should have this one taken care of in no time.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      The railways have had their share of problems lately, which seems to come in waves. You are correct, they should have this fixed as quickly as possible. It’s a money thing, and when it come to that, railways are highly motivated.

  17. Willis says:

    “The bridge, built in 1912…”
    There’s your problem. Maybe it’s time to build a new one.

    • ChrisBigDoer says:

      Actually the bridge’s age has little to do with it. Railways always over engineer and over build and a century old structure is nothing odd, and this one had no trouble carrying the much heavier trains of today. Even a new bridge could have suffered the same failure – it was after all a record flood, a once in a lifetime event and no one could have really planned for that. That it lasted as long as it did speaks of its robust construction.

  18. Stephens Family says:

    Wowzers, that bridge is now officially toast. This must be a total nightmare for CP Rail. That bridge is going to have to be completely replaced. Let’s hope that the bridge doesn’t collapse further.

You cannot copy content of this page

Please log-in to continue...
This allows unrestricted access to every post @BIGDoer.com, popups are eliminated,
commenting is on and the "contact us" page is enabled.

Esc to close this box.

Lost Password?

Or...

Your social site may send you a routine notice of login.

Or signup, here: Subscriber Register
___
BIGDoer.com: Serving up POP HISTORY & other McFun!…(Mmmm, yummy bite-sized pieces.)
One million plus words & tens of thousands of photos!